com.salmanff.vulog

The developer has not defined a format for this record.

author: null
_owner: null
description: The wave of enthusiasm around generative networks feels like another Imagenet moment - a step change in what ‘AI’ can do that could generalise far beyond the cool demos. What can it create, and where are the humans in the loop?
domainApp: benedict evans
image: http://static1.squarespace.com/static/50363cf324ac8e905e7df861/t/639997a380800648445acf3f/1671010211384/B4AAC213-3764-4A49-A1F1-CA18B3368CF0.jpeg?format=1500w
keywords: []
path: null
purl: https://www.ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2022/12/14/ChatGPT-imagenet
title: ChatGPT and the Imagenet moment — Benedict Evans
type: article
url: https://www.ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2022/12/14/ChatGPT-imagenet
date: null
vComments: null
vulog_favIconUrl: null
vHighlights: [{"id":"1671658125416-546","vCreated":1671658125416,"focusNode":[{"nodeId":"block-764303a9f7f81c1c59ae"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":3,"type":"p"},{"index":0,"type":"text"}],"focusOffset":861,"anchorNode":[{"nodeId":"block-764303a9f7f81c1c59ae"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":3,"type":"p"},{"index":0,"type":"text"}],"string":"Instead of people trying to write rules for the machine to apply to data, we give the data and the answers to the machine and it calculates the rules. This works tremendously well, and generalises far beyond images, but comes with the inherent limitation that such systems have no structural understanding of the question - they don’t necessarily have any concept of eyes or legs, let alone ‘cats’. ","color":"green","tester":"","container":[{"nodeId":"block-764303a9f7f81c1c59ae"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":3,"type":"p"}],"displayErr":false,"anchorOffset":462,"vNote":""},{"id":"1671658242756-848","vCreated":1671658242756,"focusNode":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":1,"type":"p"},{"index":6,"type":"text"}],"focusOffset":720,"anchorNode":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":1,"type":"p"},{"index":6,"type":"text"}],"string":"If I ask for ‘the chest burster scheme in Alien as directed by Wes Anderson’ and get a 92% accurate output, no-one will complain that Sigourney Weaver had a different hair style. But if I ask for some JavaScript, or a contract, I might get a ‘98% accurate’ result that looks a lot like the JavaScript I asked for, but the 2% error might break the whole thing. To put this another way, some kinds of request don’t really have wrong answers, some can be roughly right, and some can only be precisely right or wrong, and cannot be ‘98% correct’.","color":"green","tester":"","container":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":1,"type":"p"}],"displayErr":false,"anchorOffset":178,"vNote":""},{"id":"1671658608529-721","vCreated":1671658608529,"focusNode":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":10,"type":"p"},{"index":0,"type":"text"}],"focusOffset":788,"anchorNode":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":10,"type":"p"},{"index":0,"type":"text"}],"string":"Yahoo tried paying people to catalogue the entire web one site at a time, and that was unscalable. Google, on one side, is based on the patterns of aggregate human behaviour of the web, and on the other side it gives you ten results and makes you pick one - manual curation by billions of users. The index is made by machine, but the corpus it indexes is made by people and the results are chosen by people. In much the same way, generative networks, so far, rely on one side on patterns in things that people already created, and on the other on people having new ideas to type into the prompt and picking the ones that are good","color":"green","tester":"","container":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":10,"type":"p"}],"displayErr":false,"anchorOffset":159,"vNote":""},{"id":"1671658999339-967","vCreated":1671658999340,"focusNode":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":11,"type":"p"},{"index":0,"type":"text"}],"focusOffset":575,"anchorNode":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":11,"type":"p"},{"index":0,"type":"text"}],"string":"But the other side of this is that ML gives you not infinite interns but one intern with super-human speed and memory - one intern who can listen to a billion calls and say ‘you know, after 300m calls, I noticed a pattern you didn’t know about…’","vComments":[{"creator":"salman@https://www.salmanff.com","vCreated":1671659590832,"text":"Actually what ML gives you is not only depth (ie the ability to “listen to - billion calls”) but also breadth: the ability to read a thousand books on psychology and persuasion tactics and other unrelated subjects and tie them into its conclusions. What is human ingenuity other than adding patterns from two seemingly unrelated subjects together? Perhaps ML will be brilliant - or perhaps our human ingenuity is just much simpler than assumed ."}],"color":"green","tester":"","container":[{"nodeId":"block-yui_3_17_2_1_1671005354407_85567"},{"index":0,"type":"div"},{"index":11,"type":"p"}],"anchorOffset":330,"displayErr":false,"vNote":""}]
_id: @salman/com.salmanff.vulog.marks/63a1e9d079672b00161a3f57
_app_table: com.salmanff.vulog.marks
__date_published: 12/21/2022, 10:13:51 PM
_original_id: "63a1e9d079672b00161a3f57"
_fields: {"fj_modified_locally":{"type":"string","description":" "},"url":{"type":"string","description":" "},"domainApp":{"type":"string","description":" "},"type":{"type":"string","description":" "},"author":{"type":"string","description":" "},"description":{"type":"string","description":" "},"keywords":{"type":"string","description":" "},"other":{"type":"string","description":" "},"vNote":{"type":"string","description":" "},"vStars":{"type":"string","description":" "},"vHighlights":{"type":"object","description":" "},"vComments":{"type":"object","description":" "},"vSource":{"type":"string","description":""},"vulog_msg_type":{"type":"string","description":" "},"vCreated":{"type":"string","description":" "},"vulog_ttl_time":{"type":"string","description":" "},"vulog_max_scroll":{"type":"string","description":" "},"vuLog_height":{"type":"string","description":" "},"temp_unknown_tags":{"type":"string","description":" "},"tabid":{"type":"string","description":" "},"fj_deleted":{"type":"string","description":" "},"purl":{"type":"string","description":" "},"title":{"type":"string","description":" "}}
__date_modified: 2/21/2023, 10:50:03 AM
__date_created: 2/21/2023, 10:50:03 AM
Published by: salman on 12/21/2022